Hinduism & Modernity
As India continues its rapid modernization and integration into the global economy, an intense debate has emerged domestically about the role of religion, especially Hinduism, the country's historically dominant faith, in modern Indian society. Recent incidents like the controversy generated by Indian Space Research Organization (ISRO) Chairman S. Somnath visiting the famous Tirupati Venkatachalapathy temple to offer prayers and perform rituals shortly before the launch of India's Chandrayaan 3 lunar mission have highlighted the perceived conflict between traditional Hindu beliefs and practices and India's continuing scientific and technological progress.
However, simplistically characterizing Hinduism as fundamentally incompatible or at odds with modern science reflects a superficial, old-fashioned, and reductionist understanding of this ancient yet dynamic religious tradition. Unlike Abrahamic faiths, which posit a single omnipotent deity who revealed absolute truths to prophets that followers must accept as literal divine words, Hinduism embraces a range of philosophical perspectives and encourages metaphorical, symbolic, and allegorical readings of its sacred texts, granting considerable flexibility to adapt beliefs to new empirical discoveries and scientific paradigms without violating central tenets. This philosophical openness and reluctance to dogmatically privilege revealed truths over evidence has allowed many prominent Indian scientists and pioneers in technology to maintain a substantial personal Hindu identity and faith along with their rigorous research, refusing to see any inherent contradiction. For instance, the observance of traditions like performing homam fire rituals is commonplace even among highly educated Indian academics, technologists, and scientists who view such practices as spiritually fulfilling, culturally meaningful acts, not in opposition to their professional work in secular, rational fields.
While ever-shrinking parts of Hindu-majority India remain plagued by superstitious beliefs, fraudulent gurus, rejection of modern medicine, and other pseudo-scientific practices, these trends owe more to a lack of access to education and economic opportunities than Hinduism. Leading modern Hindu organizations and reformist movements have strongly promoted scientific literacy, critical thinking, and the scientific method to counter unscientific beliefs and practices that stem from poverty and ignorance, not religious scriptures. Modern Hindu reform movements like the Arya Samaj, founded in 1875 by Dayananda Saraswati, have explicitly worked to counter superstitious and unscientific practices that arose in Hindu communities. They promoted education in science, mathematics, and Western medicine to show that true Hindu philosophy is compatible with reason and scientific empiricism.
Other Hindu leaders like Vivekananda emphasized scientific thinking and critical examination of all beliefs rather than blind faith. He taught that poverty and lack of education had corrupted Hinduism over time, leading to ignorant practices, not the actual Vedic scriptures. Contemporary Hindu organizations continue this reform effort by campaigning against superstitions, condemning exploitative gurus and occult practices, and promoting scientific literacy and critical thinking that align with authentic Hindu spirituality. They emphasize that true Hinduism is open-minded, questioning human authority and dogma. Therefore, superstitious beliefs stem from human ignorance, not Hindu teachings themselves. Reclaiming Hinduism's rational philosophical core can counter unscientific practices that have no real religious mandate.
The effects of this lingering Orientalist stigma against Hinduism as incompatible with modernity are particularly concerning when examining various cultural adjustment challenges and mental health implications faced by young Indian Americans growing up between two different worlds. Many feel intensely torn between their inherited ethnic, cultural, and religious heritage centered around Hindu traditions and spirituality on the one hand and the predominantly Westernized, Christianity-influenced secular academic and social environments they must actively navigate and achieve success within on the other.
The frequent negative and orientalist portrayals of Hinduism in mainstream American pop culture, media, and even biased academic curricula, coupled with the lack of education or open discussion about the positive contributions of their ancestral faith, often leads to internalized self-stigma, intense confusion regarding self-identity during the crucial years of adolescent development, and a lingering sense of alienation or perceived inferiority surrounding their family background. Furthermore, this atmosphere understandably contributes directly to elevated risks of bullying, social isolation, microaggressions, or overt discrimination that Indian-American youth may tragically face within schools and social circles as their peers absorb and insensitively perpetuate misconceptions about Hinduism as a primitive or strange faith.
Some even condemn Hindu traditions they may observe their Indian-American friends participating in, exacerbating identity conflict and vulnerability during the already challenging teenage years. Developing interventions to promote accurate education and interfaith understanding of Hindu philosophy and its compatibility with scientific advancement could help prevent and counteract such severely harmful psychological effects and cultural alienation at a vulnerable age that no child should endure.
The concerns also extend to Indian-American college students, who frequently report needing to hide or downplay their religious heritage to better fit into campus life and social situations dominated by secular white peers, leading to further identity fragmentation. Those confident enough to openly embrace their Hindu roots report facing exotification or tokenization instead of true belonging. Collectively, these troubling experiences of young Indian Americans underscore how much work remains done by educational institutions, interfaith groups, and the media to overturn residual Orientalist narratives that generate such detrimental effects. Accurately illuminating Hinduism's positive contributions and natural alignment with science can help alleviate this pernicious but often overlooked cultural challenge for young people of Indian descent growing up between two worlds in America today.
Nevertheless, entrenched Orientalist attitudes in the media and the West have long propagated reductive stereotypes of Hinduism among the general public as superstitious, irrational, and incompatible with modernity. Consequently, many Indian and Indian-American youths feel forced to abandon outward expressions of their Hindu heritage to better assimilate into mainstream "modern" life, which they view as defined by secularism. This alienation from their ancestral faith remains a cultural and psychological challenge. Increased interfaith awareness programs and accurate education about Hindu philosophy and practice in Indian-American Hindu temples and religious organizations urgently need to combat this alienation.
Some critics may argue that pointing to unscientific practices and beliefs within segments of Hindu society proves that Hinduism as a whole is fundamentally irrational, regressive, and anti-science. However, this conclusion reflects a simplistic, disingenuous, and overly reductionist understanding of how religiosity and scientific temper typically co-evolve in cultures over time. Virtually every significant religious community across cultures and civilizational history has, at different points, had to grapple with and contend against superstitious beliefs, fraudulent claims, and irrational dogma that emerge due to human ignorance, the need for certainty, and discernible patterns in the natural world that lend themselves to supernatural explanation.
Equating those collateral products of human psychology with the core philosophical teachings of the religious tradition itself is an inherently faulty overgeneralization. Christianity as a faith went through a similar historical dynamic during its early development and medieval ages, where dogmatic church authority often suppressed freedom of inquiry and scientific advancement, which were seen as threats to the religion's power and exclusive truth claims. However, religion eventually adapted and made room for scientific progress, ushering in phenomena like the Scientific Revolution. Hinduism's inherent philosophical openness, non-dogmatic worldview, and pluralistic underpinnings make it even better positioned than Christianity to achieve such reform without requiring major concessions from or existential crises within the spiritual tradition.
Additionally, some militant atheists and critics with more scientistic worldviews argue that the advancement of science increasingly leaves no epistemological place for religion or faith traditions like Hinduism in the modern world. However, this position reflects a category error and lack of understanding of science vs. faith's legitimate domains. The scientific method and evidence-based reasoning alone cannot provide satisfying answers to more metaphysical, ethical, and existential questions about the ultimate meaning and purpose of life or human morality. Faith traditions speak to dimensions of the human experience that transcend the purview of empirical science, even as modern physics reveals the limits of material reductionism. Hinduism's ancient recognition of complementary paths to truth makes its alignment with science in the appropriate ethical and material spheres uniquely fruitful. It offers the best of both worlds - the promotion of rationality and human flourishing through science coupled with timeless spiritual wisdom that nourishes the soul.
Therefore, there is no inherent reason why reason and faith cannot positively coexist when adequately understood - dogma naturally yields to open and evidence-based inquiry when not socialized as an immutable divine mandate, the open-architecture approach Hinduism has championed since antiquity through its emphasis on experience over belief. Its vision of reconciliation of scientific advancement and spiritual meaning seems more relevant in the complex modernization journey. Far from being a relic of the past incompatible with progress like critics caricature it, Hinduism may offer an enlightening path to integrate science and spirituality toward human betterment that warrants deeper understanding and emulation.
Reframing dominant Orientalist narratives requires nuance, empathy, and resisting oversimplification. Dismissing the entire Hindu faith tradition as regressive and primitive is biased and unfair. Nevertheless, denying that outdated beliefs and discriminatory practices sanctioned by questionable scriptural interpretations exist within segments of contemporary Hindu society is also unproductive and apologetic. Indian reformers have often skillfully negotiated this delicate balance, upholding Hinduism's tolerant, pluralistic essence as a humanizing force while gently catalyzing necessary social progress against abuses sanctioned by distorted interpretations of scripture.
Human Rights & Mental Health Advocacy Newsletter is a reader-supported publication. Please become a free or paid subscriber to receive new posts and support my work.
India must continue on this sensitive path of addressing internal cultural problems and conflicts with humility while not compromising the sophistication and richness of its indigenous philosophical traditions. Ultimately, no society can thrive and unleash human potential by fragmenting itself from its cultural bedrock. Faith and technological progress must be reconciled and synthesized to unlock humanity's profound promise. Developing a more sophisticated understanding of Hinduism's integral role in India's past and future is essential to realizing this harmonious vision.
